Indiana Mr. Baseball Award
| Name | Year |
|---|---|
| Carter Mathison | 2021 |
| Michael Doolin | 2019 |
| Nick Schnell | 2018 |
| T.J Collett | 2016 |
| Logan Sowers | 2014 |
| Justin O'Conner | 2010 |
| Tucker Barnhart | 2009 |
| Alex Meyer | 2008 |
| Lance Lynn | 2005 |
| Tim LeMasters | 2004 |
| Clayton Richard | 2003 |
| Adam Lind | 2002 |
| Wes Whisler | 2001 |
| Jim Brauer | 2000 |
| J.D Closser | 1998 |
| Matt Mauck | 1997 |
| A.J. Zapp | 1996 |
| Scott Rolen | 1993 |
Prep Baseball Report POY award winners
| NAME | YEAR |
|---|---|
| Carter Mathison | 2021 |
| Michael Doolin | 2019 |
| Nick Schnell | 2018 |
| Dre Jameson | 2017 |
| Nick Prather | 2016 |
Indiana Gatorade Player of the Year
| Name | Year |
|---|---|
| Max Clark | 2021 |
| Michael Doolin | 2019 |
| Nick Schnell | 2018 |
| T.J. Collett | 2016 |
| Justin O'Conner | 2010 |
| Cameron Perkins | 2009 |
| Alex Meyer | 2008 |
| Lance Lynn | 2005 |
| Jeff Cunningham | 2004 |
| Robbie Wooley | 2003 |
| Adam Lind | 2002 |
| Garrett Burger | 2001 |
| David Beigh | 2000 |
| Rob Bowen | 1999 |
| Andy Brown | 1998 |
| Aaron Heilman | 1997 |
| Scott Rolen | 1993 |